a man and woman sit at a table during a party looking despondent

Movie Review: Gentle Monster

It’s a parent’s nightmare to wake up one morning and learn that their spouse has been accused of possessing and possibly distributing child pornography, and that is precisely what happens to avant garde pianist Lucy Weiss (Léa Seydoux) in Marie Kreutzer’s Gentle Monster. Her otherwise happy marriage to documentary filmmaker Philip (Laurence Rupp) had already hit one rough patch, with the pair and their young son Johnny (Malo Blanchet) relocating to the countryside after he experienced a nervous breakdown. But being awakened by detective Elsa Kühn (Jella Haase) and a team of officers executing a search warrant and confiscating her husband’s electronic devices causes her to instantly begin questioning how well she knows him. When she learns what he is actually accused of doing, she quite understandably spirals, fleeing the house with Johnny to stay at her mother Eloise’s (Catherine Deneuve).

Feeling like she has no one to talk to, Lucy keeps reaching out to Elsa, and while the young detective feels sympathetic to her plight, she is restricted in what she can say due to the ongoing investigation and has her own problems to deal with regarding her aging father Hermann (Sylvester Groth). Questions swirl around whether Philip is actually guilty or whether it’s all a big misunderstanding—and what the difference between the two even might be—while Lucy grapples with her disgust at his alleged crimes and her lingering feelings of affection towards him, while trying to ensure the safety and wellbeing of her son above all else.

While stately and sedate, the thorny subject matter and powerhouse performances keep the viewer riveted as we move closer to the truth, or as much of it as anyone can hope for. It proves somewhat predictable, with the title even acting as a sort of spoiler, but I don’t think the mystery around Philip’s actions is really the point, rather we are being asked to examine our own thoughts on how much we would be willing to tolerate for someone we love as well as what drives a person to commit predatory acts against another, regardless of age. Kreutzer may not provide answers for either, which may frustrate some, but that isn’t the job of fiction, rather it can be used to provoke thoughtful interrogation of difficult subjects, helping us as individuals and a society to reckon with them.

Entertaining without ever feeling lurid, Gentle Monster leaves a mark. Like an artier, more thoughtful take on an average episode of Law & Order: SVU, the film disturbs without wallowing in misery. A memorable, thoroughly modern tragedy that still feels sadly timeless. ★★★★

Rated R for sexuality, graphic nudity, and some language.

5 Star Ratings System. 5 is excellent, 3 is good, and 1 is poor.

Leave a Reply