an old painting of a harbor town, with part of a hand drawn treble clef imposed on top of it

Book Review: Music Against the Night by Yiyun Li

While quite famous in his time, the composer and pianist John Field has been all but reduced to a mere footnote in musical history. Largely credited with the creation of the nocturne and cited as an influence on more widely remembered figures like Chopin, Brahms, Liszt, Mendelssohn, and Schumann, neither his name or his works are commonly known today—though they do still get performed and recorded, which has to count for something.

These sorts of lesser-known figures are like catnip for historical fiction novelists, offering up a readymade plot with ample room for invention, and Yiyun Li (Things in Nature Merely Grow) makes brilliant use of the lives of Field and his wife Adelaide Percheron aka Percherette, of whom even less is known. In Music Against the Night, she follows each of their childhoods as they make their way from very different places gradually towards each other, through decisions both made by and for them, with only brief flashes of the future interspersed throughout.

John begins life in Ireland, where his musician father and grandfather realize he is a prodigy on the piano and begin expending all of their energies on training him to become the next Mozart, often to the detriment of his siblings’ upbringings. His life is more or less dictated for him as his fame begins to grow and the family relocates to London, where he becomes renowned enough to leave them behind and begin following instructors and benefactors instead.

Where John is meek and suggestible, Percherette is strong-willed and seemingly wise beyond her years. An orphan with some French lineage, she is brought up by a modestly wealthy family in Pondicherry, India. Much like John, she is being groomed for a future in which she will have very little say, but unlike him she wants something more. Drawn to music, she yearns to sail to France and become a renowned pianist in her own right.

We follow as both children make their way through and around the world, zeroing in on seemingly small moments that nevertheless prove important in their formation as people. Each learns of the often-indistinguishable nature of love and friendship, how fate can override the best laid plans of children and adults, and to avoid becoming too attached to people or places, a sad necessity to make it ahead in the world they were born into.

In elegant, evocative prose, Li draws us fully into their stories. Imminently quotable lines are spread liberally throughout, using the presumed naïvety of the young to lay bare the amusingly peculiar and often cruel nature of life. Moving, thought-provoking, funny, and wise, this is a sumptuous symphony of a novel. While this is the first in a planned trilogy, it works perfectly well on its own, as Li carries us along to what may be the saddest happy ending of the year. That said, it’s such a joy to read that one can’t help but feel eager to return to these characters. ★★★★★

Button Borrow AFPL
Button Buy on Bookshop
Buy from Barnes & Noble

5 Star Ratings System. 5 is excellent, 3 is good, and 1 is poor.

Leave a Reply