two dirty soldiers lie in cover amid war wreckage

Movie Review: The Mosquito Bowl

I’ve never read Buzz Bissinger’s nonfiction book of the same name, so I can’t say how close director Peter Berg and his co-writer Mark L. Smith stick to it, though given that it’s a true story I would imagine they are pretty similar. Not that fidelity to the source material is a useful metric for judging a film’s quality, but it can help to ascertain precisely where any flaws originated, and while The Mosquito Bowl is undeniably effective in places, it is pretty flawed.

After the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor in 1941, a disparate group of promising college football players—John McLaughry (Nicholas Galitzine), Bob Bauman (Bill Skarsgård), Tony Butkovich (Ray Nicholson, and Dave Schreiner (Tom Francis)—enlisted in the Marines to fight for their country. While they ostensibly had at least some understanding of the danger they faced, when they embark on their first assault they are stunned by the sheer scale of the violence that confronts them. The fighting takes an understandable toll on the men and their fellow soldiers, and so the USO show put on during a break spent at the base in Guadalcanal does little to lift their spirits. Noticing the tension, the generals task the quartet with arranging a football game.

Surprisingly, that game takes up very little of the movie’s 2-hour runtime, with virtually no build up and effectively no payoff. Given as it is preceded by an extended sequence of truly harrowing and grisly war violence, it does lift the viewer’s spirits as effectively as the players’, as the consistently excellent cast convey how much joy one can derive from being allowed to do something you love and excel at. But the movie strangely avoids giving the game any stakes and then promptly follows it up with another gruesome—though historically significant—battle sequence, leaving one to wonder what the point of the game being included even was.

There is some value to portraying the true horror of war on screen, to hopefully remind those who would so glibly send our young men and women off to fight of just how high a cost it asks of them, but this is hardly the first or best movie to do so. The main stars do what they can getting us to care for their characters as much as possible despite how thinly sketched they are. A few casting decisions baffle to the point of distraction however, most notably sports analyst Pat McAfee giving his best (not good) R. Lee Ermey impression as a drill sergeant, while the frenetic editing makes it challenging to follow the action and is oddly carried through into the film’s more sedate moments as well.

That said, Berg is as least competent as a director, so for as much as the material can feel like a blood and gore-soaked endurance test, it still manages to wring some emotion out of the viewer. You might be better served to watch the countless better war films that are visually referenced here, but these men’s sacrifices deserve to be remembered. For all its missteps, you’re unlikely to forget The Mosquito Bowl. ★★★

Rated R for intense sequences of graphic war violence, grisly images, and language throughout.

5 Star Ratings System. 5 is excellent, 3 is good, and 1 is poor.

Leave a Reply